June Sig Vote!!

[analogZero]

mistakes? nobody gave you a red pen. They're not competing for a spot on the wall at the louvre, you just pick the one you think is best out of them all.

[AyumiBee]

Originally Posted by CryticX

It was, it's not worth my time to describe how many mistakes there were there. But it's peoples art and self esteem, usually I'd crush it. I will bad today so i won't.

Why would you crush it? There's a chance there are others whos doesn't like your art. And I think the participents weren't proffisionals like Viesta, Jason ect. I welcome every critism if you point out my mistakes in the right manners. But saying that they extremely sucked is just makes us feel loosers, don't you think we tried hard? For example I was very happy when I made that sig, I liked it but you are ruining my mood. If you didn't like it say it but choose the proper manner. Thank you.

There's no reason to get upset if someone says your art stinks, I've been told plenty of times, SO? Get over yourself, simply get better and strive to learn more. I really don't care about your personal opinions, and neither should you care about mine. You want real critisizm? Here ya go:

1: I guess it's is very original but it needs a focal point, clearly not found, the composition is terrible and the text is barely readable. There is too much white (void) space.

2: If it was just snoopy without the extra dog it would have been fine, but the dog needed to be blended in more. The top left text is terrible and it has no light source. The dog needs to be slightly sharper. Decent overall.

3: This would have been good without the text, and a bit more sharpening. Also, the antialising could be removed a bit.

4. This one got my vote, dunno who you are, but all this one needed to be good is sharpening the lady, and a adjustment layer photo filter of orange.

I hope that was better critic. I hope next time you notice when a person is joking...I never crushed anyone, and if you get upset at a petty comment like that....what do you get upset at in real life, I wonder?

I did pick the best one as I think. Thank you. Calling Jason and Viesta professionals is dumb, they would be rated as novice to moderate on a grphics forum, jeez....I'm sure they know it themselves. I'm not claiming that I'm good, I just know whats good.

[analogZero]

you should take into account that some of us (and by some of us I speak only for myself) don't actually try. Mostly because I'm not going to put professional effort into a sig contest (that would be stupid and time consuming).

[wi_sam]

waah there, just stfu and enjoy the ride. all of you.

[leerock89]

Well, everyone knows who won this round so Im sure I dont have to make a new thread to declare the winner.